Skip to content
Otherside Life
The Library/Long-Form/Heal With DeathNovember 18, 2026

The Library · Long-Form · 6 min read

Why We Only Journal About Pain (and Why That Matters)

Most journals are a record of the worst days. Here is why people write when it hurts, what those pages are worth, and how to keep them safe next to the good days.

By Victoria Holmes · November 18, 2026

Victoria HolmesVictoria HolmesBirth & Death DoulaNovember 18, 20266 min read
On this page

Pull an old journal off a shelf and read it from the first page. The early entries start with good intentions and a date, and then the pages thin out. Several weeks pass with nothing. Then a run of long, cramped entries appears, written fast, with crossings-out, about a breakup, a diagnosis, a job that went wrong or a parent who stopped calling. Another silence follows. Another storm of writing. By the end the whole volume reads like a weather report for the worst years of someone's life, and the person who wrote it looks up and realises that the happiest stretch of the decade left almost no trace.

People write when things hurt, and the pages they produce are the most honest record of how they became who they are. Pain shapes a person, and the entries written in the dark places hold the evidence of that process. We find the most light in the dark places, and a journal that captures only the dark is a record that deserves to be kept safe and read alongside the good days it left out.

People journal when they are in pain because writing is where pressure goes

The pattern shows up so consistently that it hardly needs explaining. A good day absorbs itself. The dinner is eaten, the friends go home, the walk is finished, and the day closes without leaving anything unresolved. A hard day leaves residue. The conversation keeps replaying, the decision keeps tilting, and the feeling has nowhere to go. A notebook offers a place that will listen without interrupting, advising or getting tired, and writing becomes the way a person puts down something too heavy to carry through the night.

Research on expressive writing, which began with the psychologist James Pennebaker in the 1980s, has examined what happens when people write about difficult experiences, and the findings are modest and mixed, with some benefit to mood and stress for some people. Our article on whether writing about pain helps covers what the studies do and do not show. The point here is simpler. People reach for a pen at the hardest moments of their lives whether or not a study tells them to, and what they write in those moments becomes a record.

Pain-heavy journals are the most honest record of who you became

The entries from the hard years show you at the moment of decision. They contain the first draft of the sentence you later said to a friend, the doubt before the leap, the grief before the acceptance and the plan before the plan worked. A person reading them years later sees how much was survived, and how many of the things they now take for granted were once open questions. The entries are uncomfortable, and they are also evidence that the writer got through.

The record matters to other people as well. A child reading a parent's journal after their death finds out that the parent they knew as steady was once frightened, and that the steadiness was earned. A grandchild discovers that a grandfather who rarely spoke about the war wrote about it for years. Entries about pain are often the most generous thing a person leaves, because they show the people who come after that struggle is survivable and shared.

A journal that only holds pain gives a false picture of a life

The difficulty is balance. When the bad days are written down and the good days are not, a journal can suggest that a life was sadder than it was. A reader in fifty years could reasonably conclude that the writer was always unhappy, when in fact the writer spent most of their time on ordinary contentment that never seemed worth recording. Rereading can distort the writer's own memory too. After a rough decade, a person who opens the notebook can find that their sense of those years has been quietly rewritten by the pages that survived.

The remedy is to record the good days, deliberately and briefly. A line about the afternoon the light was perfect, a note about a meal, a photograph of a friend laughing, a voice note describing a small victory. These entries take two minutes and change the balance of the record. They also train attention, because the habit of writing down good moments makes them easier to notice as they happen.

Journals about pain are often lost, hidden or never read

Where the journals end up is the second problem. Many people hide them, because the contents are private and sometimes raw. The notebooks go into a drawer, a box in the attic or a folder with an unrelated name. Others are destroyed in a moment of embarrassment, which is a loss the writer often regrets within a year. Digital journals sit in apps that get abandoned, on phones that get replaced or in accounts that no one else can open. A record that took years to produce disappears in an afternoon of house clearing.

The writer is left with two bad choices. They can keep the journal where anyone might read it, or they can hide it so well that no one ever will. A third choice exists, which is to keep it somewhere safe and decide deliberately who sees it, if anyone, and when.

Keep the hard entries somewhere safe and put the good days beside them

On Otherside, entries go onto a lifeline, a private record of memories placed on the day they happened, in text, photos, video or voice notes. Each entry carries its own visibility: private, shared with your circle, shared with specific people, scheduled for a later date, or held until After I'm Gone. A raw entry about a hard year can stay entirely private for as long as you wish. A reflective entry about what that year taught you can be shared with someone who is going through something similar. The good days sit on the same line, so anyone reading, including you, sees both.

The aim is to keep the whole record in one place, protected, with the writer in charge. An entry saved today can be read, revised, shared or left alone in ten years, and the choice stays with you.

Eight prompts for writing about pain and what it taught you

These prompts are written for reflection and for the days when the writing feels possible. They are not a substitute for professional support, and anyone struggling with a heavy loss or overwhelming feelings is encouraged to talk to a doctor, counsellor or trusted person.

  1. Describe the hardest year of your life in three sentences, then add one sentence about something good that happened in the same year.
  2. Write about a day when you did not think you would get through something, and name the first small thing that helped.
  3. List three things you believe now that you did not believe before your hardest time.
  4. Write a note to the person you were at the worst moment, saying what you wish they had known.
  5. Name a person who showed up for you, and describe exactly what they did.
  6. Write about something you lost and something you found as a result.
  7. Describe a good day from a hard season, however small, and give it a full page.
  8. Finish this sentence five times: "The pain taught me..."

For a larger set of prompts written for grief, see our collection of grief journaling prompts. For the reasons grief hurts as much as it does, read why grief hurts.

Otherside Life · The LibraryEnd

Common questions

Why do I only journal when I am sad?
Difficult days leave unresolved feeling, and writing gives that feeling somewhere to go. Good days tend to close on their own, so they rarely feel like they need recording. Many people share this pattern.
Is it unhealthy to only write about negative things?
Writing about difficult experiences is common and can help some people process them. Reading back a journal that holds only hard days can skew your memory of a period, so adding short notes about good days gives a fuller picture.
Should I keep or throw away old journals?
Many people regret destroying them, and the choice is personal. If a journal feels too raw to keep in the open, store it somewhere private and decide later. A secure digital copy preserves the content without leaving it on a shelf.
Who should read my journal after I die?
That depends on what is in it and who you trust. Some people choose to leave selected entries to a child or a close friend, and others prefer that everything stays private. Deciding in advance, and setting the visibility, avoids leaving the decision to whoever finds it first.

Filed under

Written by
Victoria Holmes
Focus
Families, Grief

Victoria Holmes

Birth & Death Doula

15 years at the beginning and end of life. She will sit bedside with the dying, be with your family in the room, and stay when everyone else goes home.

Otherside Life coordinates; care is provided by the practitioner. Coordination only. Not legal, tax, financial, medical advice or funeral services.

More long-form