Every so often, society is fortunate to get a mirror held up to it, and Laika's stop-motion fantasy Wildwood, released in October, is one. The film places a grieving mother at the centre of a story for young audiences, and the reactions to it put what all of us think about the relationship between children and grief on view. Some see a story that gives grief a shape, others see content to be kept back until a child is old enough. Each reaction shows what the person reacting believes children's stories are for, whether the truths of life belong in them, and what adults owe children when it comes to death, which is either to introduce it or to wait and let it introduce itself if misfortune allows. Hoping for the best and assuming death will never reach a particular child is a position too, and it is a form of the sheltered thinking this article examines, one that adults can find in themselves as easily as in anyone else. So who is the moral panic about Wildwood really protecting? Children's discomfort, or ours?
Wildwood has reopened the argument over whether grief belongs in children's films
Laika's animated film Wildwood reached cinemas on 23 October. In an interview with Empire in July, director Travis Knight described the grief of the character Alexandra as the catalyst for the story, the loss that sets everything else in motion. A family film that makes a grieving character the engine of its plot is an uncommon choice, and the reaction to that choice has been divided.
The Plugged In review reads the film's grief as an adult's grief. After the death of 12-year-old Alexei, Alexandra's pain turns toward dark magic and a plan to sacrifice Mac. The reviewer describes the film as a cautionary story about grieving well and moving on, which puts the lesson in what a bereaved adult does with loss.
The same review leads its parent guidance with the darkness of the film and calls the opening death scene a "deal killer for many families". For those parents, the grief in the story is the reason to stay away from it.
Common Sense Media rates the film 11 and up, citing prolonged violence, dead bodies throughout and scenes of an apparent suicide and a mother holding her dead child. Its parent reviewers say 13 and up and call the themes too dark for younger viewers, and one Christian parent objects to the blood sacrifice and occult imagery. Across these reviews the grief at the centre of the film is treated as content to be rated and filtered, and the question put to parents is how old a child has to be before it is acceptable.
The Raising Children Network, an Australian parenting guide, rates the film M, not for under 12s, with parental guidance for 12 to 14s and acceptable for over 15s. Here grief becomes a subject for family conversation, and the guide places the age at which children are ready for that conversation between 12 and 15. But what about when death doesn't wait for a child to turn 12 before coming knocking?
A counter-argument comes from a YouTube Short, that some children have lost family members, some are being oppressed, and some are fighting for their rights in violent ways, and that these children need stories with characters they can relate to and triumphant moments. The creator adds that conversations about what counts as children's media tend to picture privileged children, that children with idyllic childhoods can handle darker themes, and that stories should be shaped around the full range of experiences children live through, with the privileged children no longer the only ones considered. The Short shows that the reaction to Wildwood is partly a reaction about which children a story is for. We as a society decided that stories were one of the most suitable ways to teach children lessons for life, for their captivating colours and fun visuals, but the medium becoming "childish" normalized only teaching children "childish" subject matter. As a result, is the criteria for what we are teaching children what we think they can handle, rather than what we think they ought to know? That is the same question the rest of this article turns on: a society that keeps grief and loss out of children's stories keeps them away from the children who are living with both.
Culture's reaction to Wildwood, and to death around children, follows the pattern of a moral panic
A moral panic is a widespread, exaggerated public fear that a specific group, behavior or subculture poses a severe threat to society's traditional values and interests. The sociologist Stanley Cohen introduced the term in his 1972 book Folk Devils and Moral Panics, and the reaction to Wildwood fits the description. The film is treated as a threat to the values of childhood: the parent review that objects to occult imagery and a blood sacrifice reads the film as a danger to the child's moral world, and the reviews that rate its death scenes as grounds to stay away treat the presence of death in a children's story as a hazard in itself. The same reaction extends to death and children altogether. In 1955 Geoffrey Gorer argued in an essay titled The Pornography of Death that death had taken over from sex as the unmentionable subject of modern British and American life, and the historian Philippe Ariès later described Western societies moving from familiar, public deaths to deaths kept out of sight in hospitals. As death left the home, fewer children saw it first-hand, and the adults raising them had less experience to draw on, which gave the instinct to shield children a cultural habit to rest on. A fear that is widely shared and rests on habit can pass for common sense, and the children who are already grieving are left to live with the silence it produces.
Protecting children from what they are not ready for and teaching them about death could be one task
One way people balance education and protection is by letting children set the pace. The usual framing sets protection against education, as if a parent has to choose between keeping a child safe from death and telling them about it. The guidance from children's grief organisations treats the two as a single task. The National Alliance for Children's Grief (NACG) publishes a practice guide that asks adults to use open-ended questions that let the young person lead, which means the child sets how much they are ready to hear and the adult supplies honest answers at that size. A seven-year-old who asks where the body goes needs a short, true answer, a fourteen-year-old needs a longer one, and in both cases the amount of information follows the child's own questions. Protection in this sense covers the pace and manner of the telling, such as a calm voice, a familiar adult and room to stop, and the subject itself stays on the table because a death in the family has already placed it in the child's life. Letting a child set the pace works inside a family, but a film or a book reaches many children at once and cannot follow each child's questions. The pace-setting approach therefore cannot settle whether death should appear uncensored in children's media, and that is the question the reaction to Wildwood raises: whether the response is moral panic or an acceptance of death as a normal subject for mass communication.
Our lack of normalization of death to children is unfair to those who already are unfortunate enough to encounter it
Children who are not taught about death still learn about it
Whether children need an education about death depends on what happens to them. For a child whose life has not yet included a death, the education is preparation, and a family can choose its timing. For a child who has lost a parent or sibling, the education is already underway, delivered by the event itself with no adult guidance attached. The Childhood Bereavement Estimation Model estimates that 1 in 11 children in the United States will lose a parent or sibling by age 18, so a policy of keeping death out of children's lives works as intended until the first death arrives. After that the child learns from experience, which is the school of hard knocks, where the lessons arrive without a teacher.
Leaving death out of children's lives is a decision that falls hardest on marginalized children
The decision to leave death out of children's stories, classrooms and conversations does not cost every child the same. The Childhood Bereavement Estimation Model finds that in 44 of 50 states, children in the lowest-income counties are more likely to be bereaved than children in the highest-income counties, so the children with the fewest resources are the most likely to meet death early and to meet it without the explanations, counselling or benefits that a better-resourced family can arrange. The YouTube Short makes the same point from the creator's side, arguing that debates about children's media tend to picture privileged children and that children who have lost family or live with oppression need stories they can relate to. The people who set norms for children's media and schooling may be more likely to come from circumstances where childhood bereavement is rarer, and that distance from the cost may be one reason there is no rush to change the norm. A silence that is comfortable for some children and costly for others tends to persist when those who bear the cost have the least say over it.
Benefits, school policies and counselling show how seriously society takes a child's loss
A society's response to child grief reaches into systems, well beyond conversations. The same model estimates that $15.5 billion in Social Security survivor benefits goes unclaimed each year. Bereaved children are more numerous where resources are thinnest, and the money meant to support them often never reaches them. The practical response of a society to child grief includes the benefit forms, the school policies on time off and the counselling that exists or does not, and those arrangements say as much as any sympathy card about how seriously a society takes a child's loss.
We have power to make a difference, but we are inept
How society responds to a grieving child shapes how they grieve for life
The reaction to Wildwood shows how society places child grief. The director describes grief as the force that drives the story, while the parent-facing reviews treat its death scenes as the reason to set an age limit or stay away. That split sits oddly beside how common childhood loss is, since the stories made for children are judged by how little of it they show.
A child's first experience of loss arrives together with a lesson in what the adults around them do with it. When adults name the death, answer questions and let the child cry or play as the day demands, the child learns that grief is an ordinary part of life that can be carried with company. When adults change the subject, lower their voices or tell the child to be strong, the child learns that grief is something to manage alone and out of sight, and that lesson tends to last. The Childhood Bereavement Estimation Model from Judi's House and the JAG Institute states that unaddressed childhood grief and trauma can lead to short- and long-term difficulties including decreased academic performance, mental health issues and early mortality.
The response that matters is therefore a social one, spread across relatives, teachers, the parents of a child's friends, the stories a child watches and the cultural habits that decide whether death is spoken about at all. When we treat grief as something to be hidden, the unexpected and unwanted side-effect of this is it teaches children what they are allowed to talk about. So how will a child be ready to talk about grief with their classmate who unexpectedly loses one of their parents?
Grief comes with an unwritten system of permission about who may talk about it. Adults are expected to speak about a loss at a funeral, in a eulogy or with a counsellor, and are supported when they do. Children are more often told to be strong, to be brave or to go and play, which gives them permission to carry the loss quietly and withholds permission to talk about it. The clichés that follow, such as "You need to be strong," mark the edge of what a child is allowed to say. The question of who may talk about grief is therefore also a question of age, and the people least invited into the conversation are the people least able to start it on their own.
The everyday reaction to a grieving child is made of small, well-meant sentences. Guidance from children's grief organisations lists the lines adults reach for, among them "You need to be strong," "They're in a better place," "Everything happens for a reason" and "Shouldn't you be over grieving by now?", and pairs them with alternatives that ask the child what they need. Each of those lines ends the conversation, because each one hands the child a conclusion where a question would have given them room. It describes the supportive behaviours as simple ones: being present without hunting for perfect words, listening without interrupting, keeping promises, pausing on advice and letting young people tell their own stories.
Adult discomfort and lack of practice drive much of the sheltering
Sheltering is usually described as protecting the child, and the evidence in this article points to a second driver, which is that adults often lack the words. Lines such as "You need to be strong" and "Everything happens for a reason" close the conversation as soon as it starts. A line that closes the conversation relieves the adult first, since the adult no longer has to hear the child's answer. Most adults have had little practice, because a family meets a death rarely and without rehearsal, and the skills the guidance asks for, which are presence, patience, open questions and keeping promises, are learned by using them. The gap sits mostly in what adults have been taught about talking to grieving children, and the children's capacity to hear the truth is rarely what limits the conversation.
The adults who lack the words were once children who were never given them. A child who is told to be strong, or whose question about a death is met with a change of subject, learns that grief is handled alone and out of sight, and that child is likely to reach adulthood with the habit of silence and no practice at anything else. Years later the same adult sits beside a grieving child, reaches for the same clichés and hands the lesson on. Each generation's silence becomes the next generation's lack of practice, and the hand-over happens in ordinary places, such as a classroom that goes quiet when a classmate's parent dies, which makes the cycle self-sustaining until someone in the chain learns to ask.
Breaking that chain does not take expertise. It takes an adult who stays. When we asked Michael Hawley, a death doula at Otherside, how adults can help a grieving child, he described what staying looks like: